The Alchemists coverSound designer and writer (eg Pelage Project) Ian Potter provides the delayed (originally due out in series 7) August 2013 Companion Chronicle The Alchemists. This First Doctor story is set before Unearthly Child and is performed by Carole Ann Ford as Susan with Wayne Forester as Pollitt and several other male characters. Update - Ian Potter’s blog has an interesting post on the sources for his 1932 Berlin - Alchemology.

Having been delayed, was it worth the wait?

The Story

The Big Finish product page gives us the following:

The TARDIS lands in Berlin in the 1930s, where Hitler and his National Socialist party are in the ascendant.

Some of the greatest scientific minds are gathering here: Einstein, Heisenberg, Planck, Schrödinger, Wigner. The people who will build the future of planet Earth.

But the Doctor and Susan have brought something with them. Something apparently harmless, something quite common. Yet something that could threaten the course of history…

Arriving in pre-war Berlin the Doctor insists on visiting the great scientists there gathered and meets up with Fritz Haber (a chemist of Jewish descent). Shortly after that the Doctor is kidnapped leaving Susan to fall foul of Pollitt after a whole host of encounters with the local criminal underbelly of Berlin. She makes her way by selling gold coins for cash to a jeweller who assists her as she makes her way round Berlin, gets captured, escapes, meets up with the Doctor (by chance) then eventually all ends well though we are treated to a sizeable discourse on the nature of time and why it can’t be changed.

The Storytelling

The story uses two interesting devices: one is a framing concept that the whole piece is a letter to Barbara about what to do if she (Susan) should no longer be in the TARDIS; the second that the gold they use in Berlin panders to a Nazi delusion with alchemy as a way to escape the economic crisis triggered by the Treaty of Versailles that would lead to Nazi Germany.

The framing device doesn’t quite convince, it works as a concept but Susan worrying about impending death or leaving the TARDIS seemed somewhat forced into continuity. The gold coin ideas is excellent though and (as a layman) I was compelled by the recreation of Berlin.

The story verged on teaching me too much about Fritz Haber but managed to skirt away from feeling like a history lesson. I did like that fact that this was pure historical and much of the story writing was excellent: there was a nice reference to the Hand of Omega, the TARDIS chameleon circuit works and so forth.

Acting and directing were also spot on and this may be one of my favourite of Carole Ann Ford’s recordings for Big Finish. I also enjoyed Wayne Forresters very different voices for his main characters and this (at times) felt nearly like a full cast recording. We have a more mature feeling Susan who is clearly not human and undergoes events that would never have been on the TV - she is drugged and brutally questioned at one point.

Final Thoughts

A decent story I would recommend anyone listen to and although Susan is somewhat of a passive character still we do get a lot of sense of her as a person (though I am not unable to completely reconcile this with the character on-screen). The synopsis suggests that the plot will centre around physicists but this is a slight red herring and a welcome one.

Over to you - any comments?