My meanderings now take me to the Five Doctors another anniversary special, this one the 20th. Unlike the 25th anniversary which would be a new story set at the time of the original (Remembrance of the Daleks reviewed here) it is a straightforward excuse to wallow in history in the mould of the 10th anniversary tale The Three Doctors (reviewed here). I found this rather nice picture here but couldn’t tell where it had originated - if anyone knows please let me know.

The edition I review is the special effects edition not the original; I am not sure as to what differences there are but it did seem mostly as I remembered from the original broadcast [if you look on wiki there is a list of differences quoted from @wavenode's notes in DWM]. Stay tuned for my thoughts!

Themes

As ever when reviewing I like to focus on a few topics, this time I have picked:

  • Production - how do I think the story was approached
  • Inclusivity - did it cover the bases it needed to
  • Story - how was it from various points of view - the Doctor(s), companions, other characters, monsters.

I then end with an overall reaction (positive in the main to save you scrolling ahead!)

Production

First off this was produced as a feature length story allowing the pacing to be different from the standard episodic format. This lends the story a sense of grandeur which I think works.

Having gone for the title Five Doctors, there were a couple of consequential issues - William Hartnell had passed away [as have Patrick Troughton and Jon Pertwee with regards the 50th anniversary] and Tom Baker wasn’t playing ball. Tom’s absence was glossed over with some judicious use of un-shown Shada footage but more had to be done to give us a First Doctor. The solution to have Richard Hurndall be the First Doctor in a similar outfit is far from ideal, but what choice was there given Tom’s non-appearance?

Lots of other faces from the past, some monsters and The Master make up the mix; I think this is a brave idea but does make the story very fragemented trying to give all these people something to do.

It is also interesting to note that this Dark Tower does resonante with the tale of Childe Roland as in the Robert Browning poem ‘Childe Roland to the Dark Tower came’.

Inclusivity

On the subject of who is in the story we are presented with a shopping list of major elements of the show - most Doctors, several companions, the Brig, The Master, Cybermen, only one Dalek and a collection of TimeLords including Rasillon.

The one thing that strikes me as odd is the Raston Warrior which could have been another alien - Sontaran perhaps?

I understand the desire to cover as much of the past 20 years as they could but there is probably a better story here lurking behind some edits. The Welsh quarry didn’t really summon up Gallifrey in my imagination either.

Story

The Doctors:

  • First Doctor - ignoring the casting he is given a clear role as the head of the family to whom every other doctor seems to look for approval. He solved the riddle correctly
  • Second Doctor - no real role beyond chatting to the Brigadier. I did wonder how we remembered the Omega adventure from Three Doctors. Nice to see the Yeti coat
  • Third Doctor - got to reverse the polarity of the neutron flow, drive Bessie and re-acquaint with Sarah Jane
  • Fourth Doctor - glossed over
  • Fifth Doctor - set in his time-line, he got to escape the game and chat to the High Council and ‘solve’ the myster of who the villain was.

Companions with a proper role:

  • Brigadier - snatched from his retirement party and got to re-kindle friendship with the Second Doctor. Had no real part to play in the story beyond punching The Master
  • K9 - almost a cameo warning his mistress about danger
  • Sarah Jane - fairly passive and not a patch on the character she became in the Sarah Jane Adventures. Her main role was to fall over and be scared
  • Susan - introduced as a surprise she was not shown being snatched (too difficult to show?) and rather faded out of the story
  • Tegan - I thought she did best out of the companions as she got to strike up new relatationships and take part in proceedings
  • Turlough - apart from some sketching at the beginning he had almost nothing to do beyond happening to be in the TARDIS.

Other Companions:

  • Jamie McCrimmon - a token appearance necessitated by availability it is a shame that Mike / Liz had already done the ‘phantoms’ trick so this was not a surprise to the viewer when he and Zoe appeared
  • Liz Shaw - a token appearance necessitated by availability but done ok throught the ‘phantom’ device
  • Mike Yates - a token appearance necessitated by availability but done ok throught the ‘phantom’ device
  • Romana II - only there by virtue of the Shada footage
  • Zoe Heriot - a token appearance necessitated by availability. She didn’t look like a Zoe I remembered, no short hair or jump-suit.

Monsters:

  • Cybermen - used to give a threat to some of the situations and also as cannon fodder
  • Daleks - poorly used, a token appearance to allow the First Doctor and Susan to recreate a classic scene from earlier encounters
  • Raston Warrior - what was this about? Could we not have had a historic monster?
  • Yeti - nice to have, shame it was obscured due to the costume falling apart.

Others:

  • Rasillon - a good idea but I got bored with the harp / ring / game / scrolls… of Rasillon which was tediously overused
  • The Master - I felt he was badly treated by the Doctor(s) and had one of the better parts to play in this story.

Overall

It may have been a bit of a hodge-podge but it was enjoyable and delivered something different and grander for the twentieth. I wonder what we will say about the fiftieth?