As series 7B ticks towards its conclusion we move onto Hide (which had been known as Phantom of the Hex) which is the second story from Neil Cross who also wrote the audience dividing episode (I liked it) The RIngs of Akhaten. I think this will be an episode that almost everybody enjoys - a classic ghost / horror story set in a country house. There’s also a tiny snippet on the BBC website where the Doctor asks Jessica Raine’s character (Emma Grayling) who Clara is, so expect some revelations!

What do I know? Let’s find out after transmission - see you there, but watch out for spoilers (and ghosts)!

The story

The setting is 1974; Caliburn House a magnificent though haunted house is being investigated by war hero Alec Palmer (wonderfully played by Dougray Scott) and empath Emma Grayling (as wonderfully played by Jessica Raine). Into this come the Eleventh Doctor and Clara and we get a reasonable 1970s style haunted house meets science story with shadows, mysterious figures in history and a scarecely glimpsed monster!

The Doctor guesses that what has happened is that someone has become lost in time and takes the TARDIS with Clara (who has no task to perform) through Earth’s history to photograph the same spot and build up an image of the time traveller (who we later learn is called Hila). Clara has an epiphany in that she grasps how alien the Doctor is and we are treated to an excellent exchange where Clara is angry that to the Doctor she is not yet born and long dead. A wonderfully tight example of time-lag or time-sickness. The Doctor tries to argue against this point but doesn’t succeed.

We then get a pocket-dimension rescue sequence that references the Eye of Harmony and uses a Metebelis III crystal! Much to and fro-ing before rescue and a fake close sequence before the Doctor realises that the lurking monster is one of a pair trying to re-unite so the threads are pulled together. There is even some matchmaking from first Clara trying to get Emma to believe that Alec loves her then from the Doctor when he tells them that Hila is their descendant!

The story telling

First to mention is the huge number of references to everything from Ghostbusters to Carry On Screaming! and the BBC has kindly put a detailed article together on this which is here.

That aside this episode was a masterpiece and the strongest of the series 7B run so far. First consider the 70s setting which was spot on - I watched some early 70s TV at the time and the whole set-up seemed convincing to me with the Doctor and Clara really sticking out as not being contemporary.

Jessica Raine is an actress of the moment with Call the Midwife being the role she is best known for and on the strength of this I am sure her performance in the anniversary documentary will be a strong one.

This story had lots of the tropes (to use a word all reviewers must use) of the scientific-horror with monsters, candles, ghosts and technology (though all that got used was an ink-chart device. We then had a pure-science explanation in that Hila was a time traveller. We had a love story between Alec and Emma and the two ‘monsters’. Beyond that the Doctor actually had an agenda of his own in wanting Emma to meet Clara and spill the beans on how she might be,

We also had Clara vs the TARDIS and the sequence where she calls the TARDIS a cow is wonderful as is the anger and frustration Clara feels when trying to deal with how alien time travel actually is.

The series arc

So we are no nearer to the identity of Clara but had some great nods to the past even if the pronunciation of Metebelis has changed. I do like the way the drips from the deep past of the show are creeping in as we approach November.

Final thoughts

A superb story that could be in the top episodes of the new series though for me I wanted a little bit more of the horror element - that is a minor gripe. In his Starburst review JR Southall gives this 8/10 which feels about right to me though I might argue up to 8.5 or even 9 once the series is over. Carlisle Who Fan on his blog talks about the continuing homage to Doctors past.

For once it seems most commentators agree - a superb piece of work!

What do you think? Best so far or lacking in something? Let me know!