Who kills the Doctor Part 2?

When the second part of the Eleventh Doctor’s second series was about to run, I posted on who did I think would kill the Doctor. My view is that it would be he himself in the astronaut suit. Since then we have had more episodes and the evidence is screaming only one name - River Song.

Have I changed my mind? Let’s look again at all the evidence…

The Candidates

I suggested the candidates were:

  • River Song
  • Amy Pond
  • Rory Williams
  • Wildcard - the Master, Captain Jack, old companion (Rose, Martha, Donna…)
  • Mad idea - Richard Nixon?
Really the only discussion now worth having (IMHO) is River or the Doctor?

River?

Surely the bookies favourite. We know she kills

a good man, the best man I ever knew.

We also have a big hint given that as a baby she walks around in an astronaut suit (why we don’t know).

We also now have the fact that she has killed him once in Let’s Kill Hitler (review here) and in that episode the miniature future people were clear that her crime was to kill the Doctor. Finally in the end of Closing Time (review here) we see River just graduated being re-recruited by the eye patch lady. Even the children singing all name River Song.

My remaining problem is her time line - she mostly knows she is in the high security (though rubbish) prison for murder yet in Impossible Astronaut (reviewed here) she doesn’t know what is happening on the beach as far as I can tell.

The Doctor?

I am stubbornly going to stick to it being the Doctor and the double-shooting being a ‘steal the regeneration’ trick. This would mean lots of timey-wimey ness. I have no real logic.

Why

This is the real question and indeed we are told there is a question that needs an answer and we are promised an explanation of The Silence (lots of Area 51 footage of things being grown); eye patches galore and (probably) the end of the River Song Arc from our point of view. We also say goodbye (again) to Amy and Rory.

Anyway October 1st is nearly here, bring it on!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. ( Log Out / Change )

You are commenting using your Twitter account. ( Log Out / Change )

You are commenting using your Facebook account. ( Log Out / Change )

You are commenting using your Google+ account. ( Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s