So with Closing Time we are promised the Eleventh Doctor in a reflective yet melancholy mood as he faces up to his impending demise. Having moved on from Mr & Mrs Williams (ok Rory and Amy) he now looks up his old mate Craig and gets mixed up with the Cybermen. Some of the trailer material even suggests that Craig may be at least partially cyber-converted which may make his child care duties interesting!
This promises to be a change of pace before the frenzy that will hit us in the final episode of this season - The Wedding of River Pond…
So how was it?
We are to imagine that 200 years have passed and just before the end the Doctor remembers to look up his old mate Craig and happens to defeat some Cybermen as he does. I quite liked the episode overall (I ignore the continuity to the final episode) though it did come across as an excuse to get Corden and Smith on screen a lot with a stock department store / monster in the cellar plot.
The good and the not so good
Good:
- Cameo from Rory and Amy. Given Karen Gillan does model this was a nice touch
- The ‘I speak baby’ stuff amused
- The Cybermat was tremendous
- A nod to the Big Finish Spare Parts origin story
- A strong sense of melancholy from the Doctor
- The Cybermen were fairly poor
- Sonic screwdriver now emits green bolts of something
- Reminiscent of the end of Tennant. Given we know the Doctor doesn’t die this is building into a ‘isn’t Moffat clever’ story for me so losing some appeal
The Story Arc
River kills the Doctor (or so it seems) and next week is all madness. The question may get answered (or even asked) and The Silence get explained. Let’s hope it’s tidy and doesn’t try and be all things to all people.

