Who kills the Doctor?


As I briefly note here, the second half of this years Dr Who will end (or so we are told) where it begun, i.e. with the death of the Doctor. I have no special insight but I thought I would use some logic and make a prediction. My approach is to list the possibilities then eliminate them one by one. Whoever is left is guilty your honour!

Obviously I will have missed something, but that’s half the fun!

The Candidates

I assume that the ‘facts’ as presented (i.e. not a clone and really the Doctor) are either vital red herrings or true. If red herrings then some kind of flesh trick.

I suggest the candidates are:

  • River Song
  • Amy Pond
  • Rory Williams
  • Wildcard - the Master, Captain Jack, old companion (Rose, Martha, Donna…)
  • Mad idea - Richard Nixon?

River

Surely the bookies favourite. We know she kills

a good man, the best man I ever knew.

We also have a big hint given that as a baby she walks around in an astronaut suit (why we don’t know).

Well you don’t trick me Mr Moffat (maybe you do); it is too obvious, plus she River would know before the setting of The Impossible Astronaut and would not be surprised at the shooting. Case dismissed. OK a 1% possibility.

Amy

Does she have a motive? I think she could kill if it were the right thing, and might well be angry over (e.g.) missing out on Melody growing up. I don’t have any compelling evidence to dismiss her claim but I am not sold either. Maybe there is a small chance - 20%

Rory

We know (as the Last Centurion) he can kill and can also bring himself to do difficult things. I (like the case of Amy) don’t know that he doesn’t so I will give him a reasonable chance - 30%

Wildcards

We could have the return of a major character (Jack meets River anyone?!) but do I believe this? No. Some rumours suggest ex-companions appear in Let’s Kill Hitler but let’s wait and see. What chance - 5%

Richard Nixon

I think the White House / Nixon will occur again as it was a big call to make the set and include the ex-President. Popular opinion also makes it believable that he could kill (though this would be for a reason). Is there a chance - maybe 10%

Who kills the Doctor?

My answer is in the title ‘Who’ kills the Doctor. Yes I believe he kills himself (though why he then goes back under water I don’t know). I think this is the most likely answer as it is (I think) the most left field. Chance - 80%.

Why

This is the real question, given I don’t think it is a friend the question is why (and maybe why in this fashion - that will be so that the Silence witness it and some other convoluted reason). What could the reason be - maybe it is the impending twelfth Doctor (though the Valeyard was later). I think it will be to do with the Dr becoming a bad guy (and hence the whole Melody / River Story).

Is he really dead? Well he can’t be (or no more shows!) so this must be a bizarre way to fix a temporal mistake or more likely this is a not quite real Doctor / time lord copy / running out of ideas.

Anyway episode 8 on the 27th of August so episode 13 on October 1st. Bring it on!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. ( Log Out / Change )

You are commenting using your Twitter account. ( Log Out / Change )

You are commenting using your Facebook account. ( Log Out / Change )

You are commenting using your Google+ account. ( Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s