Another bargain from the third series Companion Chronicle sale, this is a Fifth Doctor tale narrated by Sarah Sutton as Nyssa and written by Stewart Sheargold. Ken Bentley directed and the other part was played by Derek Carlyle as the Dar Traders which Stewart also used in a Seventh Doctor story The Death Collectors (which I have not read as of the time of writing).
Having had a rather mixed reaction to several of the other third series tales I was hoping for an upbeat, punchy tale - naive given the name! How was it? Read on…
The Story
The synopsis from the Big Finish product page is:
A new adventure with the Fifth Doctor as told by his companion, Nyssa.
While investigating a debris-littered battlefield in deep space, the TARDIS crew are salvaged by an ancient race of collectors known as Dar Traders.
Separated from the Doctor after an accident, Adric, Tegan and Nyssa find themselves at the mercy of the Traders’ curiosity. But the Traders have salvaged a cabinet from the battle that could be very dangerous indeed.
What does the suave assassin, Damasin Hyde, know of the cabinet? And why is everybody so interested in the missing Time Lord?
To find the Doctor, the TARDIS crew will have to enter a violent inter-planetary war. Where someone will die, and it will change everything.
The framing story is Nyssa trying to reassure a sick patient by telling a tale of hope and possibility.
The inner story starts with the TARDIS (as ever) diverted by ‘something’ and we end up in the debris of a space battle. The TARDIS crew find they can breathe as the Dar Traders (who trade people’s deaths with them) are they salvaging. The Doctor gets split away and taken down to a planet leaving Nyssa, Tegan and Adric to follow the Traders.
Nyssa trades her death and we also find a mysterious dwarf-star metal cabinet (I thought steampunk coffin when I listened) in which is an unkillable assassin Damasin Hyde. Hyde’s first action? Kill Adric!
Adric, of course, didn’t die (here) and the plot moves on to the journey to the planet to get to Hyde’s ship to repair his cabinet, The Doctor giving up some ‘life energy’ and Nyssa taking on the Assassin by using a graft she tears from the assassin’s neck.
All ends well, the assassin is defeated and we pop back to the framing story and find the patient is (maybe) slightly convinced.
The Production
Very odd for me; Sarah does herself, Tegan, Adric and Hyde with Derek Carlyle having a relatively minor (though interesting part) as the Dar Traders. The Traders reminded my a bit of the Faction Paradox - just imagery not a criticism.
The dialogue really irritated me with lots of ‘said the Doctor’ in Nyssa’s narrative which was very prominent at the start and never went away. I never have this problem on other Companion Chronicles. I wonder if Sarah had too many parts and maybe more characters should have been parked on the planet. Maybe Carlyle should have been the assassin as well.
Overall
A dark plot with lots of imagery that didn’t impress me at all. Thankfully I know the Companion Chronicles is better than this something I might have been disappointed with had I subscribed at the time.
Enough of me, what did you think? What have I overlooked? Let me know
Tony, February 2013
