It is written… 1,001 Nights reviewed

December 2012 brought us the collection of short stories known as 1,001 Nights. This four story suite features the Fifth Doctor with Nyssa and is has an overall structure to it that makes this rather refreshing compared to other such collections that can be more arbitrary in their linking.

Having set the scene, is it a collection worthy of a sultan’s pleasure or a miserable set of tales a camel would be insulted to be in? Rest assured, dear reader, this is a set of tales worthy of Scheherazade.

The structure

Written by (variously) Emma Beeby and Gordon Rennie (The Doomsday Quatrain), Jonathan Barnes (numerous) and Catherine Harvey (Recorded Time) and directed by Barnaby Edwards, this features a framing story with three stories within it.

The framing story is derived from the classic Scheherazade 1,001 nights set-up in which Nyssa has to tell the Sultan tales of adventure to stop The Doctor from being executed. The three other stories are some of tales told by Nyssa.

The tales

Big Finish have yet to release the names of the individual stories, so:

  • Framing Story - here Nyssa tells her tales to the Sultan not knowing that he is an alien who absorbs identities through stories! He ends up replacing the Doctor no less
  • Story 2 - a tale of a prison planet with one warder and one prisoner and the means by which the Doctor offers them both redemption having explored their identities
  • Story 3 - Nyssa is possessed and left in Victorian England while the Doctor seeks a cure. AS the story progresses we wonder who else is also not who they seem
  • Story 4 - a more comic tale of a world where stories are currency. This is a story in a story in a story and even gets away with a dark and stormy night in all the mayhem of deception and abduction!

Where this set works is that we not only have a frame but also each inner story echoes the ideas of the outer story with ideas of prisoners / deception / identity being neatly contrasted.

This is clever stuff!

Performances

For a change (for me) some long overdue credit for Sarah Sutton as Nyssa with some great versatility (the screaming in the possession story if nothing else! A star turn also from Alexander Siddig as the Sultan (he has been in other stories such as Wreck of the Titan and Sisters of the Flame / The Vengeance of Morbius.

Conclusion

This collection raises the bar for all such future collections (which seem to come along every year) and I hope that Big Finish maintains this level of craftsmanship.

Anyway, that’s what I thought - what did you make of it?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. ( Log Out / Change )

You are commenting using your Twitter account. ( Log Out / Change )

You are commenting using your Facebook account. ( Log Out / Change )

You are commenting using your Google+ account. ( Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s