
The story

Amidst a fairly lightweight story, some rather tokenistic comedians and plenty of CGI there were some very special moments as we realise how this episode loops round the timelines of the Doctor and River in such a way as to complement and complete Silence in the Library. It was like one of those long meals where the best part was the dessert and amidst a somewhat forgettable story Capaldi and Kingston showed just how much they can bring to the parts.
The storytelling
The story needed the froth
I’ve seen plenty of people express disappointment at this story. I do think this could have been a more classic episode with some trim and polish, but you rarely get a success with just sixty minutes of intense drama. The story needed the froth to make the poignant parts work better. Moffat pulled off a great variation of the plot where one person meets someone close to them but remains unknown. In some respects it’s a bit like the scene in Voyage of the Dawntreader where Lucy spies on a schoolfriend and hears how she speaks about her. There is a lot of this in Husbands with the Doctor seeing how River can be without the filter of knowing she is with him.
Should she have figured it out earlier? Yes, in real life; for the purposes of the story, no. Maybe not a classic as is, but rather good in a few important places and the gift of the sonic was rather splendid.
Thoughts?


