Renaissance of the Daleks reviewed

renaissance of the daleksRenaissance of the Daleks by Christopher Bidmead is a story for the Fifth Doctor and Nyssa. As the tile reveals it is also another outing for the Daleks. It’s fair to say the Mr Bidmead is not a fan favourite amongst most of the Big Finish audience and his other outing The Hollows of Time I thought was pretty poor.

Does this fare any better?

The story

As always the Big Finish product page provides something to get out teeth into:

A random landing in London and a trip to the Savoy Hotel yield unexpected results for the Doctor. Tea, scones, an American general who knows far too much, and the threat of a Dalek invasion of Earth.

Meanwhile, the Doctor’s companion Nyssa is in Rhodes during the time of the Crusades, where her position proves to be distinctly precarious.

It seems the Doctor’s deadliest foes have woven a tangled web indeed. And in order to defeat them, he must cross the forbidden barriers of time and walk into the very centre of their latest, most outlandish scheme of conquest.

For the most part this story drifts between chaotic and trying to drop in too much science (something I didn’t like in Logopolis at the time it was broadcast - bubble memory still gives me the shudders). Why is Nyssa in Rhodes? Why does the TARDIS need to pick up three random people from various bits of history plus a spy? Why do we have miniature Daleks (then nano-Daleks)? More important, what happened to the Dalek Invasion of Earth? (It is one of life’s strange moments of synchronicity [not coincidence] that I just today posted about the same story in Masters of Earth.

It’s not all dire - yes we have the place where time tracks converge, a ridiculous Dalek plan involving the nano-Daleks as a plague. Did I mention the interocitor? This is overdone in the extreme and allows for all sort of trans-temporal communications to make the plot work. OK it stays in the TARDIS for Lucie Miller to use much later on, but still.

Essential lots of random things come together to allow some random science and history to magically come together and solve everything.

The storytelling

Actually in places this isn’t too bad and there is a story lurking somewhere. The fourth disc actually flows well and Davison is in decent form. Once the story focussed on being a story it isn’t too bad. Unfortunately it is shackled by everything that was thrown in to get the players to the endgame.

I was most taken by Nicholas Deal

Of the new characters who briefly travel in the TARDIS I was most taken by Nicholas Deal who played mediaeval knight Mulberry. Nicholas has also voice characters in some UNIT stories and some other odd bits (Unbound and Seven Keys to Doomsday). It may just be his voice but he was easily the best realised new character.

I do suspect that with a different writer this might have been at least half-decent. For me, though, it didn’t make it.

Thoughts?

About Tony Jones

Writer, blogger, reviewer, and Doctor Who fan
Bookmark the permalink.