
The book covers various scripts / ideas for re-launching Who with a strong US connection in order (as I understand it) to better inform fans who at the time were worried that the series might be broken by the way it was evolving. Of course so much time has passed that this seems more of a footnote to history than an important piece of evidence.
There is a 2003 edition which may well have moved the narrative on given the context of the new TV show
Synopsis
I read this in short order; it is a synopsis of seven scripts with lots of footnotes and the odd interview. Short narratives link the scripts together and provide context. Jean-Marc was clearly well places and involved in some of the latter scripts to give some comments on continuity.
I kept reading and thinking ‘So What?’ Time has passed and the show is back. The nth Doctor is obsessed with canonising every last element of each script even down to invoking alternate histories; given these did not get made and would have evolved before hitting the screen (and even the TV show struggles to stay consistent) I found most of the book to be a fool’s errand.
What I was more interested in (which is also covered) is how the actual context for the Eight Doctor one-off TV appearance (reviewed here) arrived and also elements that survived to the TV re-launch.
What survived?
First off Paul McGann - yes he was signed up towards the latter part of the evolution and of course became the Eighth Doctor. Other things include more of an action adventure style (whatever that means) and ideas such as Gallifrey being either at war with the Daleks or having been destroyed.
The ‘part-human’ on my mother’s side is introduced in the last few scripts and a common theme in many is a romantic link between the Doctor and his companion.
Other ideas on the periphery include: being descended from Rassilon and being the Master’s brother and the Master manipulating the Daleks against the Time Lords maybe being why the Daleks execute him at the start of The Movie.
There are several ‘why it a police box’ ideas which I am pleased didn’t survive.
Is it worth reading?
For me this is little more than a curio and did not illuminate me very much at all. I cant recommend even to die hard completists (who probably bought it when it came out!)




